Think Out Loud

Portlanders in Districts 3 and 4 have large slate of choices in Nov. election

By Allison Frost (OPB)
Oct. 5, 2026 8:47 p.m. Updated: Oct. 5, 2026 8:56 p.m.

Broadcast: Monday, Oct. 5

Listen to audio from OPB journalists
00:00
 / 
15:31

Portland voters in two of the city’s four districts will soon be casting ballots to elect or re-elect their city councilors. It’s the second election using ranked-choice voting. With half of the Portland city council seats up for grabs, what should voters expect?

THANKS TO OUR SPONSOR:

We hear from OPB politics reporters Bryce Dole and Alex Zielinski as they discuss the upcoming Portland election on a recent episode of “OPB Politics Now.”

Note: The following transcript was transcribed digitally and validated for accuracy, readability and formatting by an OPB volunteer.

Dave Miller: This is Think Out Loud on OPB. I’m Dave Miller. Portland voters in two of the city’s four districts will soon be casting ballots for their city councilors. It’s the second election using ranked-choice voting. With half of Portland’s City Council seats up for grabs, what can voters expect? This was the subject of a recent episode of the OPB Politics Now podcast. It was hosted by political reporters Bryce Dole and Alex Zielinski. I’ll let Bryce take it from here.

Bryce Dole: Alex, let’s talk about the races coming up. You spent pretty much every day, probably including weekends sometimes, talking to city councilors and their staff. How are they viewing this upcoming election? What are you hearing from them right now?

Alex Zelinski: Well, as a reminder, six seats are up for election this year in Districts 3 and 4, and six city councilors in those seats want to keep their jobs, so they’re hustling. In many ways, the last two years have been an extended campaign for them; because of the major government overhaul in 2024, half of the 12 councilors came in with just a two-year term and the other half a normal four-year term, as a way to eventually balance out council elections, so they alternate every couple of years.

Dole: I see.

Zelinski: But that means, long story short, six councilors have had a very small amount of time to get anything done before running for election again. So it’s kind of blended together what is campaigning and what is actually running and being a councilor. But yes, I’d say most incumbent councilors feel somewhat optimistic about their chances in November, but the overarching vibe is uncertainty.

Dole: OK.

Zelinski: No one wants to jinx it. Here’s how Councilor Eric Zimmerman, who is in District 4, put it to me:

Councilor Zimmerman: I’m taking the perspective that we will rest on November 4 because I’m taking absolutely nothing for granted.

Zelinski: So there are still a lot of unknowns about how this new electoral system works.

Dole: OK, so let’s take a step back a little bit to bring our listeners back up to the present moment. The 2024 election was Portland’s first using ranked-choice voting, as we remember, and it was also the first under this new form of government, bringing in this new form of government. Can you just remind us how candidates approached that election? Can you remember what they were saying to you at the time?

Zelinski: Yeah, that election, as you noted, was unprecedented in so many ways. We had all twelve Council seats open, where people were being elected to represent brand new geographic districts, and they were elected with a very unique type of ranked-choice voting, which didn’t have much analysis in the U.S., and we were the guinea pig. So a lot of uncertainty. It was a lot of just throwing things at the wall and seeing what would stick.

One theme we saw was a lot of like-minded candidates running as a slate together, where they would tell voters, hey, rank me first, and then rank so-and-so second, because with ranked choice voting, at least this style of it, if a person you rank first collects enough votes to win, the second ranked candidate gets an added boost. So it felt beneficial to partner up. So we saw a lot of that.

Dole: So it was kind of like, the hope was that things would trickle down to them as a second or a third choice.

Zelinski: There wasn’t a lot of opposition campaigns. It was pretty much like kumbaya – folks campaigning together and hopeful that that would help them.

Dole: Right, I remember this. And the whole goal of ranked-choice voting was to ultimately usher in elected leaders that better represent the city, its electorate, its people. How has that worked out?

Zelinski: You know, it’s hard to find anyone who disagrees that this worked as intended. We now have a very, extremely representative elected body, with more people representing certain demographics; like people living in far East Portland neighborhoods, people of color, queer people, more than ever before. We also have this nearly perfect ideological split on city council with six more progressive councilors and six more moderate, all Democrats, of course, this is Portland ...

Dole: Right.

Zelinski: …but that division has led to some breakdowns on council with votes stalled, with a tie, and people unable to compromise on an issue. Some members of the public see this as a negative result of ranked-choice voting. That it’s almost too perfectly balanced and too representative, but I spoke with one political science professor at PSU, Melody Valdini, who says that this is actually the expected side effect. Here she is:

Melody Valdini: I remind people, this is going to increase the representation of this institution, and that is not necessarily easy or, you know, it doesn’t make things easier when lots of different voices are heard in government. It’s gonna make it harder to compromise and to be efficient, and that’s exactly what we’ve seen in the Portland City Council this year, all of these 6-6 ties, all of this back and forth and back and forth.

Zelinski: Her argument is that it’s on councilors to really find their way to work effectively within the system. I should say I’ve also heard the flip, that councilors aren’t incentivized to compromise and so it’s on the electoral system to fix it. So either way, yes, we do have a more representative council.

THANKS TO OUR SPONSOR:

Dole: I see. So, there are six seats up for grabs this year. What seems to be the biggest difference heading into this election, compared to the last one? What have you noticed?

Zelinski: I mean, it’s incumbents. Last time around, all of these seats were vacant. Now we have six people who have been able to spend the past two years demonstrating what they’re able to do, and if nothing else, get name recognition in the community. Incumbents have always had a leg up in city races, but it’s looking like it might be even easier for incumbents to keep their office under this new form of government.

Dole: OK. And why is that?

Zelinski: So the ranked-choice system means voters get one ballot to rank their district representatives, their top preferences, and that will eventually lead to three winners per district. Because of the way those votes are calculated, candidates only need 25% of the vote plus one vote to win. In the 2024 race, that meant about 21,000 votes in District 3, 19,000 votes in District 4. That’s not that many people ...

Dole: No, no.

Zelinski: … and it means that if you piss off maybe 75% of your voters but you still have the love of your base, 25% plus one, it’s not too hard to win reelection. So that’s where some of the confidence in some of these incumbents is coming from. You know, I heard specifically from District 4 Councilor Mitch Green, who has been in the press for a number of controversies recently and is now being hit with a pretty well-funded opposition campaign but seems pretty certain that his core supporters, the most progressive voters in District 4, will reelect him because he’s met their expectations in the past few years, and he’s really not trying to please everyone. He thinks he just kind of needs to focus on that base, and he doesn’t think he needs to look beyond those folks that already have him in the corner.

Dole: Gotcha. So incumbents, for the most part, are pretty safe, is what you’re saying. Are any of them vulnerable by this point?

Zelinski: Yeah, that’s an interesting question. I do want to say I’m not certain about any of these things. Like, incumbents feel safe, but who knows? I do think that the District 4 race is a good example of why there might be some vulnerabilities. In that district we have one progressive councilor, Mitch Green, who I just mentioned, and two more moderate councilors, Olivia Clark and Eric Zimmerman, who you heard at the top. The political analysts I spoke with all seem to agree that this reflects the political makeup of that district, that there are slightly more moderate voters than lefties and that it’ll be hard to see those seats flipping to candidates with different politics.

With that in mind, there is a campaign led by moderate advocacy groups pushing to elect a candidate named Eli Arnold. This campaign is very opposed to Green and wants to replace him with Arnold. The problem is that Arnold’s politics are moderate, very aligned with Zimmerman and Clark, and he’s not specifically going after Green’s voters. He is a Portland police officer. He kind of falls into this category of more moderate, not a member of the DSA or anything like that.

Doug Moore is the head of United for Portland. It’s a PAC that backs more moderate candidates, and he’s also a politics nerd. He spent the last two years analyzing how the 2024 election went down, and he told me he’s pretty confident that if Arnold wins, it would be from picking up votes from Zimmerman or Clark, not Green’s votes. So Arnold’s popularity could hypothetically risk Zimmerman or Clark’s re-election, but not easily. Here’s Doug Moore:

Doug Moore: But it takes a candidate who is very similar ideologically to you to sort of displace you from that seat. Especially now, this cycle, with the built-in name ID, it’s gonna take a real effort to elevate a candidate to the point where they’re gonna have equivalent levels of name ID.

Zelinski: So it’s a challenge, but it is a real threat, and I think this is why Councilor Zimmerman in particular, whose tape we heard earlier, that’s why he isn’t resting until after election day. He’s a little nervous that his seat could be maybe unintentionally grabbed by someone like Arnold. I should note here that Arnold isn’t campaigning against Zimmerman at all. There’s no anti-Zimmerman stuff in his campaign materials. It’s mostly critical against Green. So we’ll see how those chips fall.

Dole: Right. It’s interesting to think about, yeah, how that all lays out. A moment ago, you were talking about how in the previous election, some candidates were kind of banding together and saying, “Rank me alongside this other candidate.” How are candidates campaigning this time around, just differently compared to the last time? I mean, are we still seeing people banding together in this way? Are people kind of staying in their own campaigns? Like, what are you seeing? What are you noticing?

Zelinski: Yeah, I mean, for one, we are not seeing as many people partnering up as we did in 2024, and I think some candidates believe that that technique backfired, and they see being ranked first as the top priority. Not, “Oh, hey, if you rank that person first, put me second.”

You can kind of take a look at the 2024 election results to understand that logic. Almost every single councilor who won collected the most number of first-ranked votes in the city, so they would have won with or without ranked-choice. Basically, people won who got that first rank, and so partnering up and kind of being second place or third place might not be that effective. Here’s how one candidate for District 4, Jamey Evenstar, put it to me:

Jamey Evenstar: One of the lessons we did learn from that first election is that you do have to get enough number one ranks. It’s not going to be enough for you to be a mention on a ballot in second, third, fourth place, to really get into the top three.

Zelinski: So I’m seeing this attitude reflected in the District 3 race. In 2024, we saw two similar candidates, Tiffany Koyama Lane and Angelita Morillo, holding many campaign events together, and they both won. This year, they’re still doing that, but a little less so. I spoke with Koyama Lane, and she said she’s focusing more this year on going door-knocking on her own to really get her name out there solo, than doing this partnership with Morillo where they go door-knocking together and have these events together.

It’s tricky because these two counselors are very ideologically similar. So, under that previous theory I mentioned, it’s going to be hard to replace someone who’s already similar to you. It could be that they could be a threat to each other’s reelection, but they could not. I mean, it’s still very like, who knows?

Dole: Who knows, right? I mean, we should clarify, too, we don’t have a lot of, or any elections, really, throughout the country to compare this to, like there’s not really…

Zelinski: There’s stuff, globally, but it’s very different, in these different places that have this, so it’s hard to know exactly what to anticipate, which kind of makes it fun.

Dole: It is. Yeah, and interesting, and I remember, in covering the proposal for statewide ranked-choice voting, a big part of that pitch was the idea of ranking people second and ranking people third and having this option; and it’s just interesting to hear about how, at least the first time around, there were indications that those second and third rankings might not be that critically important compared to first.

Zelinski: Yeah, I mean, like you heard from Evenstar, the general feeling is that being lower ranked isn’t the goal here. I should note that there is one person who won their council seat in 2024 who didn’t get the most first ranked votes. Eleven of them did, but the one person who didn’t is Eric Zimmerman. He partnered up with Councilor Olivia Clark on the campaign trail, and she got a huge amount of votes. So being second-ranked behind her was a big boost to him being second.

I think it was different than any other district race where she just got like a big swarm of votes around the first round, so Zimmerman told me he’s sticking to that approach. He’s one of the few people that I spoke with who’s like, “Yeah, no, we’re still partnering up. This is great.” He’s holding events with Clark and leaning into that partnership. So at least one person still believes in the power of the lower rankings.

Miller: That was OPB Portland City Government Reporter Alex Zielinski talking with our political reporter Bryce Dole in a recent episode of OPB Politics Now. You can find it wherever you get your podcasts, including our own. There is also a link on our website, OPB.org/thinkoutloud.

“Think Out Loud®” broadcasts live at noon every day and rebroadcasts at 8 p.m.

If you’d like to comment on any of the topics in this show or suggest a topic of your own, please get in touch with us on Facebook, send an email to thinkoutloud@opb.org, or you can leave a voicemail for us at 503-293-1983.

THANKS TO OUR SPONSOR:

THANKS TO OUR SPONSOR: